High demands

Before I start in on this, I want to say right out that NetGalley has been a wonderful resource, and has allowed me access to more books than I know I would have been able to get otherwise. My blog isn’t huge enough to attract attention from a lot of large publishers, or even most smaller publishers, so having an account on NetGalley has expanded my literary horizons in a big way.

NetGalley isn’t the problem. The problem comes with the demands that some of the publishers make before allowing anyone access to their books.

There are some conditions that I can understand. Regular blog updates, listings of the kind of books you prefer to read, a complete bio, a few example reviews that you’ve done. That stuff’s fine, and completely understandable. But I came across one book the other day that sounded good, sounded like I’d enjoy it and be able to write a decent review of it, and so I requested it.

My request was denied. The reason? I don’t have 750+ blog followers, along with at least 500 GoodReads friends, and a few other things that pretty much meant they want me to have an insane following before they’ll even think about giving me access.

Now I’ll grant you, I don’t devote as much time as I probably should to increasing my readership. I have 54 followers through Google Friend Connect, and maybe a few more who read my blog in other ways, but I don’t have as large a following as some. I try to focus more on reading and doing good reviews than on promoting myself a lot, and maybe that’s a failing, but I’d rather have good content than a ton of followers. I want to give what followers I do have a reason to keep coming back. Admittedly, I probably should spend more time on community sites, spreading the word about my blog and gaining a few more readers.

But really, 750 followers? Hands up, all of you who are reading this and who have book review blogs of your own with that many followers. How many of you have over 500 friends on GoodReads? How many of you might have stood a chance at getting this book, which, I must say, would have been given out at practically no cost to the publisher and might have given them a few more sales.

I’m not saying I’m entitled to any book that I ask for. But it just struck me that their demands were pretty high, and in setting the bar so high, they actually eliminated a number of people who could have given them additional publicity. Restricting it to the highest few means that only the big blogs will promote it, and that fewer reviews will reach a higher number of readers, but when the cost is practically zero anyway, I have to wonder what they thought they’d be losing by allowing greater access. Did they worry that if smaller blogs were promoting it then the assumption would be that it’s the kind of book larger blogs turn down? Do they assume that blogs without hundreds of followers have no quality control on their reviews and promotions?

It made me wonder.

Have you run into this sort of thing before? Have you ever requested a book from a publisher and been told no, you’re not big enough to be considered? How did it make you feel?

One comment on “High demands

  1. That's crazy! The book blogs with that kind of readership already get sent more books they can read/review without needing to go out and ask for more.

    Know what I'm doing right now? Reading the last week's reviews from all the book blogs I follow, and writing down the books I think I might like. I'll take the list with me to B&N next time I go, and quite likely I'll buy a few of the books. I might have bought the book you'd reviewed, if only they'd let you read it first.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s